(note, the above is not Dale. Thanks and credit to whoever’s kid it is – I couldn’t find it)
So far, Sam and I have been pretty lucky with Dale. He sleeps through the entire night, says please and thank you when he wants and gets something, and is extremely compassionate with his peers at daycare. With his improving communication he can tell us pretty quickly what he wants and doesn’t want, which makes life easier on all counts. However, he’s fast approaching two and once in a while we observe evidence that there’s a dash of the terrible twos on the horizon. When a temper tantrum surfaces (more accurately, a wail and throw to the floor), we just ignore him or turn him around in his chair and within 30 seconds, he comes to his senses and returns far more agreeable than he was moments ago. If in the midst of the tantrum if he does something he knows he’s not supposed to, we sit him on our lap in the living room and endure a time out.
The time outs are as bad for me as they are for Dale. I speak sternly to him for 30 seconds, then we sit in silence for a minute and a half, then tell him I love him and he gives me a hug. The look on his face during all of this is positively enervating: he looks at the ground, doesn’t say a word, and is terrified to look up at me. Given the impact it has on him, I’m forced to review the offense he committed and I wonder how on earth throwing a carrot on the ground justified making him feel this way (note though, it’s extremely effective, because he hasn’t thrown a scrap on the floor in almost two months). The problem is, the time outs are SO effective with Dale that it’s tempting to use them to communicate other dos and don’ts.
Here’s an example: this morning he insisted on having yogurt in a cup, and when we brought it to him he complained that he didn’t want it. Then he wanted applesauce served with his snowman spatula; we gave it to him and he didn’t touch it. I told him he wasn’t going anywhere until the yogurt was finished, he finally finished it, then started complaining yet again. I concluded he needed a time out to put a stop to the fussiness and to communicate that it’s not okay to waste a bunch of food that he asked for in the first place.
Was that worth a time out? Maybe, maybe not. Sam doesn’t think so, and I’m on the fence. It did halt the fussiness to be sure, though…and that’s where it’s dangerous communication. Everyone is entitled to a bad mood, including 2-year olds, and Dale just got over the stomach flu so I feel he might be especially entitled. But I can’t take it back, only learn from it moving forward. Would I do it again? Probably not.
Don’t misinterpret this post: I’m not asking when our readers feel it’s okay to discipline your child, because the answer truly varies on the parent (how they were raised, what values they choose to uphold, how they were punished, etc) and parenting one’s child is nobody’s business but their own (and their spouse’s). I’m just conceding that there are no cut and dry rules that apply to child rearing. If Dale continues to be such a good kid, we might not have to worry about this too much.












































